Answers in this round are all foods (or food-adjacent words) that appear in the lyrics to food-based Weird Al parodies. The foods in the image reference the titles of the parodies. Use the number of each food to index into the word/phrase of the original lyric Weird Al replaces with the answer.
| Number | Food | Parody Song | Original Song | Answer in Lyric | Original Lyric | Extracted Letter |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bologna | My Bologna | My Sharona | Spreadin' on the MUSTARD now | Come a little CLOSER huh | C |
| 2 | Oreo | The White Stuff | The Right Stuff | Now Twinkies and DING DONGS won't do | And all that I WANTED was you | A |
| 1 | Chicken Pot Pie | Chicken Pot Pie* | Live and Let Die | CHICKEN POT PIE | LIVE AND LET DIE | L |
| 11 | Ice Cream | I Love Rocky Road | I Love Rock n Roll | So have another TRIPLE SCOOP with me | So come and take your TIME AND DANCE with me | C |
| 2 | Kaiser Roll | The Rye or the Kaiser (Theme from Rocky XIII) | Eye of the Tiger | You might like our SALAMI and the liver's all right | And the last known SURVIVOR stalks his prey in the night | U |
| 5 | Potato | Addicted to Spuds | Addicted to Love | POTATO SKINS, potato cakes | YOUR LIGHTS ARE ON, but you're not home | L |
| 2 | Spam | Spam | Stand | Wonder if it's MYSTERY MEAT | Wonder why you HAVEN'T BEFORE | A |
| 1 | Ice Cream | I Love Rocky Road | I Love Rock n Roll | So have another TRIPLE SCOOP with me | So come and take your TIME AND DANCE with me | T |
| 2 | Lasagna | Lasagna | La Bamba | Or a-maybe SPAGHETTI | Una poca DE GRACIA | E |
| 6 | Oreo | The White Stuff | The Right Stuff | Now Twinkies and DING DONGS won't do | And all that I WANTED was you | D |
| 2 | Grapefuit | Grapefruit Diet | Zoot Suit Riot | Fudge and Twinkies and DEVILED HAM | Pipes and chains and SWINGIN HANDS | W |
| 1 | Spam | Spam | Stand | Wonder if it's MYSTERY MEAT | Wonder why you HAVEN'T BEFORE | H |
| 6 | Potato | Addicted to Spuds | Addicted to Love | POTATO SKINS, potato cakes | YOUR LIGHTS ARE ON, but you're not home | I |
| 4 | Bologna | My Bologna | My Sharona | Spreadin' on the MUSTARD now | Come a little CLOSER huh | S |
| 6 | Taco | Taco Grande | Rico Suave | I need a QUESADILLA | I eat 'em RAW LIKE SUSHI | K |
*Not officially released, but still performed