Solution to That Sinking Feeling

Back to Puzzle

Answer: BOAT RIDE

by Anderson Wang

Each column of words (which is in alphabetical order) can be rearranged to make 10 clues of 10 words each, reading across:

ClueAnswer
Adjective describing indigenous people whose languages include Warlpiri and PitjantjatjaraABORIGINAL
Alternate name for a jawbreaker notably used by Willy WonkaGOBSTOPPER
English heavy metal band that's named for a torture deviceIRON MAIDEN
Game published by Milton Bradley that involves guessing fleet locationsBATTLESHIP
Olympic events that included dressage and show jumping in 2016EQUESTRIAN
Science Channel television series explaining the manufacturing of common objectsHOW ITS MADE
Type of art exemplified by Joseph Kosuth and Sol LeWittCONCEPTUAL
Urban theorist who opposed Robert Moses' plans for Greenwich VillageJANE JACOBS
With "muscle", disorder where someone perceives their body as smallDYSMORPHIA
Young wedding figure whose dress should match with the bride'sFLOWER GIRL

Each answer is 10 letters long and begins with a different letter from A-J, so we can reorder them in alphabetical order and color the letters red or white if the corresponding word in the clue is red or white.

ABORIGINAL
BATTLESHIP
CONCEPTUAL
DYSMORPHIA
EQUESTRIAN
FLOWERGIRL
GOBSTOPPER
HOWITSMADE
IRONMAIDEN
JANEJACOBS

The red letters, read from top to bottom, spell out APPLY ROW B. The answer beginning with B is BATTLESHIP, which clues that the red and white words correspond to guesses in a game of Battleship (where red and white pegs are used to represent hits and misses, respectively, and which also labels rows with A-J). This is also hinted at by the title and the light blue background.

In the Milton Bradley game Battleship, there are 5 ships, of sizes 5, 4, 3, 3, and 2. We can uniquely determine the positions of these ships in the given grid, using fairly simple logic (e.g., the red W needs to be part of the size-2 ship, which means the red B and P/L must be size 3 ships, and then the red A/Y is the size 4 ship and P/R/O is the size 5 ship).

The remaining ship cells, highlighted in red below, spell out the answer BOAT RIDE.

ABORIGINAL
BATTLESHIP
CONCEPTUAL
DYSMORPHIA
EQUESTRIAN
FLOWERGIRL
GOBSTOPPER
HOWITSMADE
IRONMAIDEN
JANEJACOBS

Author’s Notes

In early brainstorming for this puzzle, I wanted to have pictures (tinted red or white) represent coordinates, inspired by ET TU sounding like A2, but had trouble coming up with a good way of doing so for arbitrary coordinates. The current idea came around from brainstorming potential extractions involving a grid of letters and thinking about how the grid itself could be clued with 10-word crossword clues (and also that BATTLESHIP was 10 letters long and began with one of the first 10 letters of the alphabet).