Crack Some Crypts

by Holly Sipek, Ivan Wang, and Liam Thomas

Answer:
TWITCH

We are presented with clues formatted in the shape of “locks”. From the capitalization, we can read these clues going upwards. The title suggests they are “crypt”ic clues, and solving a few in each lock confirms that they are all the same length.

ClueAnswerExplanation
Extinct animal is discovered in mediocre ole pigeonholesCREOLEPIG_cre ole pig_
Gut parasites swap heads with basic voracious readersBOOKWORMS(H->B)OOKWORMS
Plot follows conservative with Labour leader in waveSTORYLINES(TORY+L)INE
Saint, and so forth, in back of tramSTREETCARST + RE(ETC)AR
Doctors read shift recklesslyHEADFIRST<READSHIFT>
Legislator and felon trade Tiesi for maidenLAWMAKERLAW(BRE->M)AKER
Suitable to Don's smartwatch, e.g.WEARABLEdouble def
Pole from a prow is found among rainbow spritesBOWSPRIT_bow sprit_
Offer a measure, it's said, for freebieGIVEAWAYGIVE+A+hom(WEIGH)
Sparse, as in to grasp, read, thinkSPREADTHIN_sp read thin_
Computer shortcut hears a wharf and agreement precederKEYBINDINGhom(QUAY)+ BINDING
Wet English is entangled longitudinallyLENGTHWISE<WETENGLISH>
According to Spooner, saltwater pond starts new paragraphLINEBREAKSpooner(BRINE LAKE)
Disco trades France for new Fincher filmFIGHTCLUB(N->F)IGHTCLUB
Goods are kept in this brewing Oreo stormSTOREROOM<OREOSTORM>
Puts a lid on rings for final piecesCAPSTONESCAPS+TONES
Painting life's beginning, Randy escapes without limitsLANDSCAPEL_+_and_+_scape_
Airfoils Lick Surface: feature films on waterOILSLICKS_oils lick s_
Hooligan flanks headless zombies at bedtimeLIGHTSOUTL(wIGHTS)OUT
Vital pulsation could possibly be a threatHEARTBEAT<BEATHREAT>
Ladyfinger ends and centipede heart make appendage edgeFINGERTIP_finger + _tIp_
Grade every period with penBALLPOINTB+ALL+POINT
Lofty chandelier's best partHIGHLIGHTHIGH+LIGHT
Mass earth movement led island to eruptLANDSLIDE<LEDISLAND>
Make a landing feel feathersTOUCHDOWNTOUCH+DOWN
Garment flaps and winds around wheat flourCOATTAILSCO(ATTA)ILS
Nearby pro ductworkers conceal unintentional manufacturing outputBYPRODUCT_by pro duct_

Once we’ve solved these clues, the next step is to line them up in the same way the clues are presented. A pattern in all the answers is that each word can be split into two. These resemble the pins in a pin tumbler lock, with the first and second halves mapping to the key (red) and driver (blue) pins in this diagram, respectively.

As a lockpick might do, we must use our picks to push the pins up such that they line up at the breaks in the words (as in the first example lock). Helpfully, we are given a clue and a tallest pick length, which gives an enumeration for the longest pick.

Each clue helps us fill in the missing “pick” words semantically:

  • For CinemaLock, we are looking for prefixes of movies, when combined with the key pins (e.g. KING CREOLE).
  • For Lock & Key, we are looking for words that form phrases of the format “X and Y”, where “X” is each of the key pin words (e.g. LAW AND ORDER).
  • For Open X Lock, we must find words such that “Open X” and “X Lock” are both valid phrases, when replacing Lock with a key pin word (e.g. OPEN SESAME, SESAME OIL).

The “lock” in the pick always gives the position of the key pins, while the underline indicates the part we should solve for.

Using these picks, we can fill in the grids as follows (the yellow background indicates pick):

ST
MES
GRNRR
IOIAI
PWLCF
EKYTD
LOREA
OOOEE
EBTRH
RESTR
CLOSE
GGYYS
NNKSA
IUOAR
KJTEE
CinemaLock
RT
EEIY
KLRA
ABPW
MASA
WRWE
AAOV
LEBI
RWWG
EROE
DARK
RERA
OTAT
Lock & Key
G
N
I
NDE
INS
HII
TBW
DYH
AET
EKG
RYN
PRE
SAL
EMS
DIM
IRR
WPA
Open X Lock
SS
KEEK
ABMNPC
EUOOAI
RLOTCL
BCRSSS
ETEPDL
NHRANI
IGOCAO
LITTLE
RFSETM
EEKKRA
TRORAS
AIOAEE
WFBMHS
Open X Lock
T
TN
TAPI
UEIO
OBTP
STRL
TREL
HAGA
GENB
IHIR
LEFE
YVDL
TALL
IROO
CBGR
CinemaLock
T
C
TESU
HDNLD
GIWIO
ILOAR
LSDTP
HDHTY
GNCAB
IAUOE
HLOCG
WATER
OEOIA
LSGTL
Lock & Key

Reading across, we can find one word in each lock. These are the key pins in the final lock. We can match them to the redacted cryptic clues by again looking for compound words; the final cryptic word always clues the second half by wordplay.

TALLTALES...stories
WATERFALL...stumble
LITTLETOE...digit
DARKHORSE...stallion
CLOSECALL...phone
DIMWITTED...clever

Taking this final lock, we can do-it-again using the Anti-Lock, a clue for antonyms as our pins. Reading across gives our final answer, TWITCH.

D
SEE
ELSLT
LLERLT
AAOOAI
TFTHCW
LREKEM
LELRSI
ATTAOD
TATDLT
TWITCH
RELHNG
ORGGEI
HIIIPR
SFBLOB