The sixteen paragraphs each give a description of an animated feature film written as an H. P. Lovecraft pastiche. Identified, the sixteen films are:
Each paragraph also includes an extraneous element more explicitly from Lovecraft’s writings. These correspond to the sixteen cards with distinct (nonzero) numbers in the game Lovecraft Letter:
Indexing into the film titles in the given order using the numbers of the associated cards gives the phrase FINAL FORM OF GOZER. The answer is STAY PUFT MARSHMALLOW MAN.